Federal court rules in New York's favor in non-domiciled CDL lawsuit

Wooden judge's gavel and sound block on dark background, symbolizing law and justice

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit has handed the Trump administration a setback when it ruled on Nov. 13 that the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration could not withhold funding from New York over how the state handles non-domiciled commercial driver's license issuance.

The court ruled the FMCSA could not withhold $74 million in funding because the state issued CDLs for a time that surpassed the expiration date of the applicant’s work authorization in the U.S. The three-judge panel called FMCSA's actions arbitrary and capricious.

The FMCSA took the action following an audit of numerous states' practices of issuing non-domiciled CDLs. At the time, FMCSA called New York the worst offender of not having CDL expirations match work authorization expirations.

New York successfully argued  no regulation existed to require that practice. 

California also fought the FMCSA for the same withholding of $160 million in federal funds. The outcome of that suit is pending.

The FMCSA undertook its audit of state non-domiciled CDL practices following several high-profile fatal crashes involving truckers holding non-domiciled CDLs. 

Looking for your next job?
Careersingear.com is the go-to platform for the Trucking industry. Don’t just find the job you need; find the job you want with the company that wants you!